Kobo's New E-Readers Are a Sidegrade Most Can Skip - Except for One Model

Table of Contents

The Color Conundrum

Kobo recently released a new line of e-readers, including color versions of the popular Libra 2 and Clara, as well as an updated monochrome version of the latter. After putting these devices through their paces, I’m here to say that for most users, there’s no compelling reason to upgrade.

Color E-Paper Screens: A Mixed Bag

The color editions of the Clara and Libra feature E Ink’s latest Kaleido 3 display, which has come a long way since its inception. However, the color reproduction is still not on par with what I’d expect from a modern device. The colors are desaturated, washed out, and lack vibrancy. It’s hard to enjoy comics or websites on these screens due to their poor color accuracy.

The Problem with Color

It’s unclear why anyone would want color on a 6-inch device that’s roughly the size of a pulp paperback. I tried reading comics on these devices, but the text was too small and zooming/panning was clumsy. The colors were also washed out in every shade. Perhaps a children’s book might be an exception, but for most users, it’s just not worth the compromise.

A Wide Range of Colors

Now, I want to give credit where credit is due: the screen displays a wide range of colors. In one particular panel with several distinct shades of blue, I was able to discern them on the reader almost as well as my normal LCD screen. They’re certainly desaturated, but they are there.

Moiré and Aliasing

The moiré and aliasing effects are less noticeable in person, but you get the idea. It’s clear that while Kobo has made strides in color technology, it still has a way to go before it matches the likes of an LCD screen.

Why Not Just Get the Color One?

You may be thinking: "Why not just get the color one and have the option?" Yes, you can still read ordinary books on these devices. However, unfortunately, the color layer actually makes black and white content worse.

Black and White Content Suffers

I compared the Clara Colour and BW side by side, as well as with an older Clara 2EI I had lying around. While they’re nominally the same resolution, the Colour version looks like there’s a light gauze over it, darkening the entire display slightly and reducing contrast.

A Step Down

This means that if you’re primarily reading black and white content, it’s actually better to stick with an older model or a monochrome device. The color layer doesn’t add much value in this regard.

Kobo’s Response

I reached out to Kobo for comment on these issues, but they didn’t respond before publication.

The Verdict

For most users, the new line of e-readers from Kobo is a mixed bag. While they offer some exciting features, such as color screens and improved performance, the compromises are too great in terms of color accuracy and B&W content. If you’re due for an upgrade, I’d recommend sticking with an older model or exploring other options.